This
past summer Sportscenter turned into Lebron James watch as every facet of his
life was analyzed. They even brought in an expert who had written two books on
the man. Lebron James is only thirty and he already has a resident expert on
ESPN. Where was the expert for Michael Jordan or even Wayne Gretzky? Because of
this highlights took a back seat, as it was clearly more pressing to discover
Lebron James was in Vegas today and at the world cup the next day. Instead of
seeing the great highlights from that fourteen inning baseball game, I am now
stuck to listening to three people argue over how Lebron James recent breakfast
confirms he is staying in Miami.
It was not like this all the time! Coming home from
Kindergarten I would plop down on the couch, eat a slice of leftover pizza and
become enthralled over the great home run races of the early 2000’s. Now I am
lucky to get a decent highlight concerning the tight pennant races in the MLB.
In
George Saunders’s piece, “The Braindead Megaphone”, he uses a comparison of a
loud man shouting phrases at a party in a megaphone to represent media in the
United States. He is described as, “Not the smartest person at the party or the
most experienced, or the most articulate. But he’s got the megaphone” (Saunders
240). The idea of being ‘loud and proud’ dominates the airwaves these days as
it catches your attention based on the volume coming out of your TV and not the
words coming out of the megaphone. The eloquent spoken guest with years of
experience in the field is easily drowned out, by the loud man behind the
megaphone.
ESPN
is a corporation, and to state the obvious: highlights don’t attract a lot of
viewers. So instead time is given to
analyze all of the celebrities in sports.
Programs will be dedicated to the big 3: Johnny Manziel, Lebron James
and Michael Sam. All three of these men all have a story that will help attract
viewers. One is an accomplished basketball player who left his home city to
take his talents to south beach. Another is an excellent quarterback, who is
full of swagger. And lastly we have the first openly gay player to be drafted
in the NFL. Each one of these individuals has a resident expert, and every
facet of their life is analyzed with the same six second clip being played
again and again. Sounds pretty ridiculous doesn’t it? As stated in Saunders’
piece about experts, “Dog crap expert Jesse Toville provides his assessment of
the probable size of the dog and its psychological state at the time of
crappage” (Saunders 241). In order to fill the air with their live sports
coverage, experts will be brought in to analyze the little things, which can be
comprehended by any rational human being.
A
big proponent of this downfall was the switch to live news programs. With the
prevalence of the internet and social media, news can be spread across in mere
seconds. Taped sports news programs began to lose its edge as up to date stats
could easily be searched with a few clicks of a button. Finally in 2008, ESPN
decided to air live sports centers in the morning, which had been on tape since
its inception. As executive vice president of production Norby Williamson puts
it, “Going live will allow us to put a fresh
perspective on the previous night's games and cover breaking news during the
day” (ESPN). From 6am to 3pm,
sports would be covered live in studio. On a summer week day, fifteen baseball
games were covered, possibly some NFL preseason and if it was the right year:
the Olympics. While some air time is taken up by this, it leaves a lot more
dead air to cover. That is where the dog crap experts are brought in to fill
this time with analysis of tweets and Instagram photos. Can 140 characters or
less really be analyzed for material? These experts favorite word is:
speculation. Following a week 4 defeat, ESPN analysts were quick to speculate
the demise of the patriots’ franchise. After a single game it was clear that
the patriots’ season was over, Tom Brady should retire, and all the players
hate the coaching staff. Over the following week these reports were denied by
the organization with considerable evidence. However the damage was already
done as the emotions from New England sports fan caused them to tune into other
ESPN broadcasts and have discussion on their website. As Saunders points out,
“[The voice] strives to antagonize us, make us feel anxious (Saunders 244). A
couple of white lies caused an increase in traffic and viewership, at the cost
of overall quality and validity of the program.
In order to thrive in today’s world of television,
channels strive for the most views which give them higher ratings. This then
allows them to sell ad space for even more money, which reaps them the highest
profit. This sometimes comes with a decrease in overall quality to the
material. In order to get the most viewers, which create the highest ratings,
they need to appeal to the lowest common denominator the “common sports fan”.
In New England the common sports fan is pretty easy to spot: they wear pink red
sox hats, gush over Tom Brady and hop on the bandwagon whenever a team starts
doing well. This causes sports media outlets to sensationalize the athletes
they cover, in order to appeal to this kind of market. They could care less
about me, who has shelves of sports history books and who knows the winner of
the 1979 NL MVP, as I am a species that does not represent the biggest
demographic.
Is
there any hope for sports media as a whole? Can it shy away from the sensationalized
topics and its fascination on sports’ star celebrities? There is, but the
underlying issue is with the sports industry at a whole and sports media is
only a part of the well-oiled machine. In the mid-20th century,
baseball players often took a second job in the winter as their base salary was
usually not enough. These people were just regular people who could hit a ball
with a stick better than most people. As time passed on, people realized sports
could be marketed to generate even more money. At first the championships such
as the World Series and Super Bowl were televised. Nowadays you could find
television coverage of a college scrimmage if you looked hard enough. Now that
sports could be shown in living rooms, commercials filled the dead air and were
plastered all over the stadiums. And then there was merchandising! You could
dress like your favorite player or show the world what team you rooted for with
a shirt. Logos and uniforms are changed quickly as that can generate even more
sales, as only “true” fans would be up to date with their clothing. Sports
became less about the sport itself, and more about corporations trying to get
their name out. The most athletic
players get sensationalized as the face of the franchise, which drive up merchandise
sales as even more people want that
jersey. It seems like sports media shows the people that the major leagues want
to sell as faces of their leagues. Sports media itself has now become a part of
the sports industry conglomerate as it plays an integral part of putting these
stars in the right light. Instead of providing an unbiased view inside the
industry, the industry itself has now given media an agenda to follow.
Sports media rounds out this circus as they talk about
the big name marketable players. In the
2013 Eastern Conference Finals, The Boston Bruins faced off against the
Pittsburgh Penguins. Most of the spotlight was put on the two star penguins’
players Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin. Both of these players were amazing at
their craft, handsome and easily marketable. However when the rugged bearded
Bruins swept the pretty boys from Pittsburgh, you could hear the sadness in the
national announcers voices. While the Bruins may have been the better team,
they lacked the star power that media outlets could latch onto to sell the
sport.
ESPN has now taken a spot behind the megaphone, as they
yell into it what they think should be broadcasted to the entire world. Instead
of getting well-rounded highlights from the major sports, we instead get analysis
of the biggest stars of the game in order to placate the most common sports
fan. Their views are increased by playing to emotions of certain fans, and they
sensationalize the bigger athletes to create likeable faces of leagues. Punters spend years perfecting the way they
hold the football and how they hit with their foot. However the backup
quarterback of the Cleveland Browns garners all the attention on ESPN’s
airwaves. It doesn’t matter if you’re athletic or talented. If you aren’t
deemed marketable, you will not be appearing on sports media.